Working papers results

2004 - n° 267

This paper explores the quantitative plausibility of three candidate explanations for the
European productivity slowdown with respect to the US. The empirical plausibility of the
common wisdom on the topic (the "IT usage" hypothesis) is found to crucially depend on
how IT-using industries are defined. If a narrow definition is chosen, the IT usage
hypothesis no longer explains the whole of the EU productivity slowdown but just about
55% of it, with the remaining part to be attributed to other factors than IT, as argued in the
IT irrelevance view. No room is left for IT-producing industries as another potential
vehicle for the US-EU productivity growth gap, instead.

Francesco Daveri (University of Parma and IGIER)
2004 - n° 266
Marco Da Rin (Turin University, ECGI and IGIER) and Thomas Hellmann (University of British Columbia)

Abstract

Financial intermediaries can choose the extent to which they want to be active
investors, providing valuable services like advice, support and corporate governance.
We examine the determinants of the decision to become an active financial
intermediary using a hand-collected dataset on European venture capital deals. We
find organizational specialization to be a key driver. Venture firms which are
independent and focused on venture capital alone get more involved with their
companies. The human capital of venture partners is another key driver of active
financial intermediation. Venture firms whose partners' have prior business
experience or a scientific education provide more support and governance. These
results have implications for prevailing views of financial intermediation, which largely
abstract from issues of specialization and human capital.

Laura Bottazzi (Bocconi University, IGIER and CEPR),
Keywords: Venture Capital, Corporate Governance, Human Capital, Organizations
2004 - n° 265

This paper discusses the recent literature on the role of the state in economic development.
It concludes that government incentives to enact sound policies are key to economic success.
It also discusses the evidence on what happens after episodes of economic and political
liberalizations, asking whether political liberalizations strengthen government incentives to
enact sound economic policies. The answer is mixed. Most episodes of economic
liberalizations are indeed preceded by political liberalizations. But the countries that have
done better are those that have managed to open up the economy first, and only later have
liberalized their political system.

Guido Tabellini
Keywords: Growth, Institutions and Democracy
2004 - n° 264
Guido Tabellini (IGIER, Università Bocconi)

Abstract

This paper studies empirically the effects of and the interactions amongst economic and
political liberalizations. Economic liberalizations are measured by a widely used indicator
that captures the scope of the market in the economy, and in particular of policies
towards freer international trade (cf. Sachs and Werner 1995, Wacziarg and Welch 2003).
Political liberalizations correspond to the event of becoming a democracy. Using a
difference-in-difference estimation, we ask what are the effects of liberalizations on
economic performance, on macroeconomic policy and on structural policies. The main
results concern the quantitative relevance of the feedback and interaction effects
between the two kinds of reforms. First, we find positive feedback effects between
economic and political reforms. The timing of events indicates that causality is more
likely to run from political to economic liberalizations, rather than viceversa, but we
cannot rule out feedback effects in both directions. Second, the sequence of reforms
matters. Countries that first liberalize and then become democracies do much better
than countries that pursue the opposite sequence, in almost all dimensions.

Francesco Giavazzi (IGIER, Università Bocconi) and Guido Tabellini(IGIER, Università Bocconi)
Keywords: development, democracy, economic reform, growth
2004 - n° 263

We develop a structural model of a small open economy with gradual exchange rate pass-through and endogenous inertia in inflation and output. We then estimate the model by matching the implied impulse responses with those obtained from a VAR model estimated on Swedish data. Although our model is highly stylized it captures very well the responses of output, domestic and imported inflation, the interest rate, and the real exchange rate. However, in order to account for the observed persistence in the real exchange rate and
the large deviations from UIP, we need a large and volatile premium on foreign exchange.

Jesper Lind (Sveriges Riksbank), Marianne Nessn (Sveriges Riksbank) and Ulf Soderstrom (IGIER and Università Bocconi)
Keywords: Structural open-economy model, new open-economy macroeconomics,estimation, calibration
2004 - n° 262

Firing frictions and renegotiation costs affect worker and firm preferences
for rigid wages versus individualized Nash bargaining in a standard
model of equilibrium unemployment, in which workers vary by
observable skill. Rigid wages permit savings on renegotiation costs and
prevent workers from exploiting the firing friction. For standard calibrations,
the model can account for political support for wage rigidity
by both workers and firms, especially in labor markets for intermediate
skills. The firing friction is necessary for this effect, and reinforces
the impact of both turbulence and other labor market institutions on
preferences for rigid wages.

Tito Boeri and Michael Burda
Keywords: Wage rigidities, job protection, firing taxes, renegotiation costs, equilibrium unemployment
2004 - n° 261

We analyse the evolution of the business cycle in the accession countries, after a careful examination of the seasonal properties of the available series and the required modification of the cycle dating procedures. We then focus on the degree of cyclical concordance within the group of accession countries, which turns out to be in general lower than that between the existing EU countries (the Baltic countries constitute an exception). With respect to the Eurozone, the indications of synchronization are also generally low and lower relative to the position obtaining for countries taking part in previous enlargements (with the exceptions of Poland, Slovenia and Hungary). In the light of the optimal currency area literature, these results cast doubts on the usefulness of adopting the euro in the near future for most accession countries, though other criteria such as the extent of trade and the gains in credibility may point in a different direction.

Michael Artis, Massimiliano Marcellino and Tommaso Proietti
Keywords: Business cycles, dating algorithms, cycle synchronization, EU enlargement, seasonal adjustment
2004 - n° 260

The accession of ten countries into the European Union makes the
forecasting of their key macroeconomic indicators such as GDP
growth, inflation and interest rates an exercise of some importance.
Because of the transition period, only short spans of reliable time series
are available which suggests the adoption of simple time series models
as forecasting tools, because of their parsimonious specification and
good performance. Nevertheless, despite this constraint on the span of
data, a large number of macroeconomic variables (for a given time
span) are available which are of potential use in forecasting, making the
class of dynamic factor models a reasonable alternative forecasting tool.
We compare the relative performance of the two forecasting approaches,
first by means of simulation experiments and then by using data for five
Acceding countries. We also evaluate the role of Euro-area information for
forecasting, and the usefulness of robustifying techniques such as
intercept corrections and second differencing. We find that factor models
work well in general, even though there are marked differences across
countries. Robustifying techniques are useful in a few cases, while
Euro-area information is virtually irrelevant.

Anindya Banerjee, Massimiliano Marcellino and Igor Masten
Keywords: Factor models, forecasts, time series models, Acceding countries
2004 - n° 259

The hazard rate of investment is derived within a real option model, and its properties
are analyzed in order to directly study the relation between uncertainty and investment.
Maximum likelihood estimates of the hazard are calculated using a sample of MNEs that
have invested in Central and Eastern Europe over the period 1990-1998. Employing a
standard, non-parametric specification of the hazard, our measure of uncertainty has a
negative effect on investment, but the reduced-form model is unable to control for nonlinearities
in the relationship. The structural estimation of the option-based hazard is
instead able to account for the non-linearities and exhibits a significant value of waiting,
though the latter is independent from our measure of uncertainty. This finding supports
the existence of alternative channels through which uncertainty can affect investment.

Carlo Altomonte and Enrico Pennings
Keywords: hazard rates, uncertainty, foreign investment
2004 - n° 258

Equilibrium business cycle models have typically less shocks than variables.
As pointed out by Altug, 1989 and Sargent, 1989, if variables are measured with
error, this characteristic implies that the model solution for measured variables has
a factor structure. This paper compares estimation performance for the impulse
response coefficients based on a VAR approximation to this class of models and
an estimation method that explicitly takes into account the restrictions implied
by the factor structure. Bias and mean squared error for both factor based and
VAR based estimates of impulse response functions are quantified using, as data
generating process, a calibrated standard equilibrium business cycle model. We
show that, at short horizons, VAR estimates of impulse response functions are less
accurate than factor estimates while the two methods perform similarly at medium
and long run horizons.

Domenico Giannone, Lucrezia Reichlin and Luca Sala
Working Papers search